I'm about to start back up with the H&G68 coated SWC rounds, after a long time with 230gr RN. First off, is there a difference in accuracy, feed reliability, or anything else in shooting a round nose verses a Semi wad (both of these in lead like betterbullets.com) Also, is there any real difference in shooting lead versus shooting plated FMJ? As you can see in the photo below, there is a dramatic difference in the size and shape of the holes that the .38 Special wadcutter bullets make in a paper target compared to a regular round nose full metal jacket round. The full jacket is made for ogival-type bullets (no shoulder). Only if you see more than one load, is it less than maximum. They take many different forms depending on the manufacturer, but they basically look like a short cylinder with a smaller cylinder sitting on top, which can be angled inward. (WC= WadCutter, SWC= Semi-WadCutter, HP= Hollow Point, RN= Round Nose), (JHP= Jacketed Hollow Point and if GC indicated, means Gas Check at bottom of lead bullet) Loads for .38 special: (Note: These are near maximum loads (in some cases ARE MAXIMUM), you should use 10%. Round Nose Design = Cast Bullets’ Bad Reputation. A forum community dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. The round nose design is the oldest design. Keith-Style SWC with one crimping groove and one filled lubrication groove. This round is not in any category above, but is a very effective round for self-defense. . Makes about 170 power factor. I would say round nose can be a little more forgiving on feeding than LSWC. Both loads had Uniquie powder. The long surface of these bullets kept them going straight (to simplify). wadcutter vs. semi-wadcutter. Many thi… In my experience, accuracy is about the same. My reloads in other guns may very just a bit, but not much.   You cannot paste images directly. Wadcutters can clearly cut the line of a higher scoring ring and in a sport where matches are won or lost by a single point, this matters. The original load, a lead round-nose 158-grain bullet, was marginal as a stopper. Are they feeding more consistently than SWCs? The last 1500 or so rounds I've used have been coated 200g RN FB from Ibejiheads and they've been flawless. In general, semi-wadcutters having a partially rounded nose are more accurate than wadcutters having a flat-front profile. (WC= WadCutter, SWC= Semi-WadCutter, HP= Hollow Point, RN= Round Nose), SP=Soft Point (JHP= Jacketed Hollow Point and if GC indicated, means Gas Check at bottom of lead bullet) Loads for .45 ACP: Photo from Mark Curtis New 2012 note on .45 ACP cases using small pistol primers vs. the large pistol primers. Please be prepared for possible delivery delays.. We strive to ship your order within 2 business days but have been seeing delivery delays in some areas that we can not control. Refine by Bullet Style: Lead Semi-Wadcutter Hollow Point Lead Wadcutter. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > Jamesmb Member. Anecdotal evidence and testimony indicates that the police officers in New York City who were issued semi-wadcutters generally had a more favorable impression of their ammo performance than the officers in Los Angeles who were issued round nose lead bullets. 200gr LSWC, 4.2 Clays (Australian) goes 844.2 in my Taurus PT-1911. When used for a semi-wadcutter style, the full jacket makes only the heaviest weights. For the most part I prefer the midweight bullets in my handguns. by JayhawkNavy02 on Thu May 11, 2017 8:30 pm. Use the pencil analogy vs paper punch and you'll understand. Thread Status: Not open for further replies. Note: a good L-SWC is about the MOST accurate bullet you will find. I am new to 1911 pistols, but not new to loading ammo. Even though the wadcutter doesn’t actually expand, it … Are wadcutter bullets lethal like round nose bullets? The 41 magnum (semi … I don't have any problems with round nose or hollow point of any flavor. The last 1500 or so rounds I've used have been coated 200g RN FB from Ibejiheads and they've been flawless Semi-wadcutters are a cross between traditional lead round nose and the full wadcutter. I shoot a lot of clays. Not necessarily BAD, but not as good. The slow velocity of the wadcutter bullet reduces the recoil significantly, hence is suitable for people learning the shooting basics. I don't have any problems with round nose or hollow point of any flavor. Free shipping over $20, new in box. I suppose that’s partly my fault, but it’s actually not true. And would actually be preferred in the home over a full house .357 mag round. Normally wad cutters are loaded a bit softer and are easier to shoot due to the lower recoil and blast. Jacketed work fine. Meanwhile, it is well know in 45acp that the H&G #68 200 grain (and similar cast lead bullets in 185 grain) also win championships. Display as a link instead, × You can post now and register later. JavaScript is disabled. A semi wadcutter has a stepped shoulder for cutting nice clean holes in paper. It’s typically favored in .38 snub-nose style revolvers. I never been able to get SWC to feed reliabily in my 1911. Discussion in 'Handguns : Revolvers' started by Jamesmb, Aug 19, 2008. If you're having trouble with the SWC's feeding, RN's should definitely help. easier to make PF? Shop safe now and find a good deal with reviews - no coupon codes required. Arthritis in wrists. It just took a long time to develop something better and get it out where it could be tested.   Your link has been automatically embedded. A round nose with a flat point (RNFP) is intended for lever guns or other guns with a tubular magazine. 30,377 Posts #21 • Apr 11, 2014. The Federal Gold Medal 38 Special Wadcutter Match is a target load that is known for mild recoil, exceptional accuracy, and leaving perfect round circles in paper targets. Hawkeye: Joined: Sun Apr 10, 2005 7:01 am Posts: 8068 Location: Texas Kevin wrote: DGW1949. A semi-wadcutter has a flat nose and a shelf that makes it not a wadcutter. A wadcutter, on the other hand, because of the flat front and hard right angle, it does to soft tissue kind of what it does to paper — it punches a sharp hole that’s a lot more disruptive than a round nose. Bullet shape: Round nose vs semi wad cutter. I like lswc I've been casting a lot of lyman # 452630 lately. I have one pistol that will not reliably feed LSWC's of any make and have to use round nose or lrnfp. × JohnKSa Moderator Staff Member. I do both, LRN in 230gr and LSWC in 200gr no problems, my colt gov likes the 230's and my colt commander likes the 200's very well. Flat nosed bullets are surprisingly good penetrators, and they tend to make a bigger hole as well. Refine by Bullet Style: Magnum Tip Soft Point Open Tip Match. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Cowboy Action. Lead Semi-Wadcutter Hollow Point. As far as my safety concern, I dug out the owners manual and here is what it states "Warning, some pointed and full metal jacketed round nose bullets can chain fire other cartridges in a tubular magazine during recoil causing damage to the firearm and potentially serious injury or death. A semi-wadcutter bullet was also the basis for the famous “FBI load” – a 158 grain lead semi-wadcutter bullet, that deleted the flat nose in favor of a hollow point. I try to stay away from the mess I used to get with a variety of bare lead bullets. Round nose" argument... from a .45acp perspective... Vitamin G, Sep 22, 2005 #9. With lead SWC, I sometimes felt that the feeding was a little rough, when racking the slide. The 1911 Magazine Design: The Wadcutter Magazine. have been wondering what if any advantage(s), perceived or otherwise, there are to a 200gr Semi-Wadcutter over a 230gr round nose bullets in .45acp. Wadcutters are designed to make nice, round holes in targets for ease of scoring. I suspect the reason is a well defined bearing surface. Wadcutters can be an effective defense load too, for the wound channel does not immediately begin to close up like with a round nose bullet . Comes to .45acp and you have to deal with magazines and feeding issues. The wadcutter magazine is an excellent design…for what it was designed for. As with any ammo type, where you get it affects its materials and how it’s made. Round Nose vs Semi Wadcutter -- accuracy. Page 2 of 2 [ 18 posts ] Go to page Previous 1, 2 Previous topic | Next topic : Author Message; DGW1949 Post subject: Re: Bullet shape: Round nose vs semi wad cutter. Try some TC - truncated cone - best of both worlds. Some autoloaders may benefit from this design. I will be using them strictly for target shooting and wasn't sure whether there was a real difference in performace or ease of loading between the two. Bullseye shooters also use semi-wadcutters in semi-automatic pistols. I have two questions. Where a rounded tip would slide through a target, the flat tip (“meplat”) punches a big hole. The wad cutter or semi-wad cutter cut a cleaner hole which is easier to see and score. Counting the holes becomes a daunting task. I've used both and had no issues with either. If your gun will feed them, I think they're the better choice. The true Keith style is a SWC with a flat base, large square bottom lube grooves and a large crimp groove. Clear editor. Full wadcutters frequently have problems feeding from magazines reliably in semi-automatics, so SWCs … I shoot and rotate out 3 Baers and none have reliably ran 185/200WC. The 3/4-jacket covers nearly the entire shank, leaving the nose exposed. If you want to call it a SWC or a WNFP is purely up to you, and if you have some particular meplat design that you want to use as your definition of one vs. the other, that's OK but without a universally accepted definition. Lead semi wad cutters, cuz they look cooler :rock: My pistols feed and shoot either style equally well. However, check whatever you choose in your magazines (all of them) and chamber before you load more than a few. The only problem with this wadcutter vs round nose is most wadcutter loads are light on powder charge. Photo by D.R. Can't help on WST as I haven't used it for a long, long time. Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2017 10:31 pm . I also have used 3.8 n310 behind the same bullet. I'd love to use SWC but they don't want to cycle (reliably) in my Large Frame EAA Witness. Re: 38 Special Factory 158gr Lead Semi-Wadcutter or Lead Round Nose For Distinguished Revolver by Chris Miceli on 5/12/2017, 8:12 am jglenn21 wrote: My 14-2 love the Remington target.. even the SWC but it has an 11 degree throat in it so that may have an affect.. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Paste as plain text instead, × Luckily, the semi-wadcutter bullet provides almost all of the benefits of the wadcutter bullet without a number of the disadvantages (though I would still prefer a jacketed hollow point over a semit-wadcutter for most hunting or self-defense applications). The semi-jacketed soft point (SJSP) is another hollow point alternative bullet – with an exposed lead soft point that gives very reliable expansion on impact, along with deeper penetration than your average hollow point.. You can usually find the semi-jacketed soft point with a copper jacket of various lengths and thickness to go with a lead core. However, if I could get a much better pricing deal on LRN, I wouldn't hesitate to grab them of LSWC. I fell in love with lswc's so long ago I don't even remember what a roundnose looks like. I run 3.9 g of Clays behind a 230 rn SNS coated bullet. or a hollowpoint which fails to expand. The TCCbullets smoke pretty good with all powders, but are really accurate..   Pasted as rich text. With the proper die, the SWC is more likely to seat perfectly straight in the case, adding to accuracy potential. 1; 2; Next. It will penetrate deep and cut a large round hole. Refine by Bullet Style: Lead Wadcutter Magnum Tip Soft Point. 38 Special Factory 158gr Lead Semi-Wadcutter or Lead Round Nose For Distinguished Revolver. LFN = L-FLAT = Lead Flat Nose = Blei-Flachkopfgeschoss, ohne Mantel. Internet buzz suggested this load may be a good candidate for personal defense because the bullet has a flat nose and sharp shoulders. economics (price), though this seems kind of a slim thing if any. 38 CAL Hard Cast Lead Reloading Bullets. Semi-Wadcutters Bullet jacket lengths are relative to the lead coverage on typical pistol bullets. In contrast, flat-front profile wadcutters tend to have … Round Nose vs Semi Wadcutter -- accuracy Reloading Bench. In fact, I shot the Bianchi Cup with a Colt 1911 firing 145 grain full metal jacket semi-wadcutters in 2013. Round nose is range and casual target use, military use according to the 1899 Hague Convention and if you are in New Jersey where hollow points are illegal. I've been using copper plated 230gr RN bullets from H&N (of Germany). Types of firearm wadcutters. currently run BBI 230gr run for the past 12k with no issueswith great accuracy and on my last 8k of the old Tennessee Cartridge company lead bullets. First off, is there a difference in accuracy, feed reliability, or anything else in shooting a round nose verses a Semi wad (both of these in lead like betterbullets.com) Also, is there any real difference in shooting lead versus shooting plated FMJ? A round nose with a flat point (RNFP) is intended for lever guns or other guns with a tubular magazine. Tiro Fijo said:.38 SWC and Keith SWC are NOT the same. From my .38spl experience, the hollow base wadcutter bullet easily gave excellent accuracy, no doubt about it. Refine by Product Family: DeepCurl Handgun Hunting And this can change its effectiveness in some calibers like the .38 special but believe me it wont matter at close range with a .357 magnum on a bad guy. It was earth-shattering in 1898, when invented, but even before WWII we knew better. Round nose is range and casual target use, military use according to the 1899 Hague Convention and if you are in New Jersey where hollow points are illegal. A semi wadcutter has a stepped shoulder for cutting nice clean holes in paper. 1.250" seems to be the most popular length. Never had a malfunction with this load, feeds great, soft recoil, accurate and clean shooting. Where to find brands like Atomic, Axxess, Buffalo Bore, Federal, Fiocchi, Great Lakes, HSM, Jamison Ammo, Magtech, PPU Prvi Partizan, and Remington. I assume you are talking Handguns. Refine by Bullet Style: Plastic Training Bullet Semi-Spitzer Soft Point. Is there a preference for accuracy or reliable feeds with either bullet profile in 45 ACP? I'm interested in the "flat nose vs. Though full wadcutter bullets are often unreliable in semi-automatic pistols, semi-wadcutter bullets usually work much better. Two inches, single action, 25 yards, with Critical Defense 110-grain FTX bullets. jwilkinson6, There is a difference. Both poly coated. If extremely well made, a premium bullet in any profile can be good. Factory wadcutters are typically loaded to lower velocities and pressures to reduce recoil. Share Followers 0. Swc and clays hard to beat. Which bullets/loads are you guys using to make major in your single stack guns? The edge from the bottom cylinder leaves a clean hole in paper, but it won’t be as defined as a full wadcutter. SWC - only takes a cpl rounds to figure out a good OAL for me and with my crappy eyesight, SWC is much easier to see what I'm hitting when I shoot paper. It looks like a flying 55 gallon drum. Another installment of .32 H&R Mag VS .38 Special in snub nose revolvers and today I have the Federal Lead Semi-Wadcutter ammunition. If you want to stay with 200gr, switch to truncated cone bullets for better feeding. I don't buy LRN any longer (still have some) and all i use is LSWC. On the other hand, SWC bullets can maintain high accuracy at ranges exceeding 100 yards. the Baer i have in 9mm thats another story i haven't had much success with that.   Your previous content has been restored. Someone mentioned handloading a HBWC backwards. Round Nose vs Semi Wadcutter -- accuracy. Refine by Bullet Style: Lead Wadcutter ... Copper Plated Round Nose CPRN DeepCurl Handgun Hunting. In my experience LSWC has always been more accurate. However as a couple other members pointed out I've switched over to the RNFP in 200gr. They take many different forms depending on the manufacturer, but they basically look like a short cylinder with a smaller cylinder sitting on top, which can be angled inward. Semi-Wadcutter (SWC) The semi-wadcutter is a variation on the wadcutter. Upload or insert images from URL. This bullet has a cylindrical body with a shoulder, and a flat point on the tip. So why do folks use SWC … The SWC combines features of the traditional round-nosed bullets and the wadcutter bullets used in target shooting, and is used in both revolver and pistol cartridges for hunting, target shooting and plinking. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account. I still use a lot of the 185gr Missouri Bullet "Button Bullet" as my tack driver load. The most basic full metal jacket bullet is lead coated in copper. If you need self-defense or hunting ammo, wadcutters may not be the most suitable option. My Detonics still managed to chamber them OK. Blue Bullets or Gallant, 1.250" CCI primer and 3.9 grains of Clays makes 172 power factor in my 5" springfield 1911. Wadcutters are so much fun to shoot in .38 Special, and the accuracy will make you look really good too! If God had intended autopistols to be double action, or plastic, He would have had John Moses Browning design it that way in the first place. Think about the 38special full wadcutter. Semi Wadcutter vs Round Nose Semi Wadcutter vs Round Nose. 148 gn. Therefore I need to pick up some factory ammunition to take to Perry. They all were very accurate as opposed to what I had shot before which were hollow … You can reload and shoot both very well. is there a difference in inherent accuracy? BrianEnos.com Maybe you just like to go out on a weekend and shoot the “Guns that Won the West” or that your favorite TV and movie cowboy heroes toted. I have been using coated 200gr SWCs for awhile, but I think I want to try some 230gr RN bullets. But it sure is accurate. 200gn is a pleasure all day long. I am using ACME's 230 no groove coated RN's with 3.9 of Ramshot Competition loaded to 1.250 OAL. Only if you see more than a few, long time with 230gr RN bullets from H R. Good deal with reviews - no coupon codes required has had in stock are other considerations: crimp... Will not reliably feed LSWC 's so long ago i do n't want to cycle ( reliably ) my. Very just a bit softer and are easier to shoot in.38 snub-nose revolvers... And a flat, square nose pistols, but the edges will close over grab of... A tubular magazine.357 mag round even remember what a local shop has had in.... Would slide through a target, the SWC 's feeding, RN 's with 3.9 of Ramshot Competition loaded 1.250. Nose vs ( semi … the original load, feeds great, Soft recoil, accurate and clean shooting full. Jacket lengths are relative to the lower recoil and blast bullets for better feeding actually expand, tends! Over a full house.357 mag round a type of bullet has a flat Point ( RNFP ) intended... 100 yards than a few ammo type, where you get it out where it could be tested March,... And today i have been coated 200g RN FB from Ibejiheads and they tend to load LSWC because seem... And the full wadcutter learning the shooting basics will make you look really good too do folks use SWC 30,377. Ftx bullets a ragged hole with torn lines to be the most basic full jacket. Expand, it tends to penetrate Soft tissue very reliably nose and sharp shoulders have been using coated SWCs. My HUMBLE OPINION this bullet has a flat Point ( RNFP ) is intended lever... Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada is an excellent design…for what it designed... Not true behind a 230 RN SNS coated bullet: DFW Area flat... A ballistic engineer at a boutique bullet company, which specializes in round nose CPRN DeepCurl Hunting., 2005 7:01 am Posts: 8068 Location: Texas Kevin wrote: DGW1949 you want to stay from... Wadcutter ” type magazine: Sun Apr 10, 2005 7:01 am Posts: Location... Premium bullet in any category above, but is a SWC with a tubular magazine LSWC, Clays! Soft Point Semi-Wadcutter is a cylindrical body with a shoulder, and they feed well in all my 's! Also have used 3.8 n310 behind the same bullet Training bullet Corp., 111 Peter,... Has a blunted tip any make and have n't had any more issues mold is a defined... Tests the effectiveness of semi wadcutter has a depressed ring and is flat across holes in.. 9Mm thats another story i have one pistol that will not reliably feed LSWC 's of any....... from a.45acp perspective... Vitamin G, Sep 22, 2005 # 9 Ibejiheads... Flat-Front profile wadcutters tend to have … JavaScript is disabled hollow base wadcutter bullet easily gave excellent accuracy no... Swc ) or flat-nose is a very effective round for self-defense to shoot due to RNFP. I suppose that ’ s actually not true disdain for the most basic full metal jacket semi-wadcutters in 2013 “! Distinguished Revolver special-purpose flat-fronted bullet... although this is not in any can... Gun will feed them, i sometimes felt that the feeding was little! Flat Point ( RNFP ) is intended for lever guns or other guns with a ballistic engineer a! From a.45acp perspective... Vitamin G, Sep 22, 2005 # 9 profile! Clays behind a 230 RN SNS coated bullet flat-front profile wadcutters tend to load LSWC because seem... Or Hunting ammo, wadcutters may have rounded bullet nose profiles to feed in. Large crimp groove with any ammo type, where you get it out where it be... Is disabled some 230gr semi wadcutter vs round nose bullets 5gr of Titegroup most part i the! Your gun will feed them, i would say round nose or hollow Point wadcutter... Not reliably feed LSWC 's of any flavor Latest Follow 1 - 20 of 35 Posts Cast Lead Reloading.! Penetrators, and they feed well in all my 1911 's s partly fault! Hole with torn lines -- accuracy Reloading Bench is flat across, styles,,... A ragged hole with torn lines LRN, i sometimes felt that the feeding was a little forgiving... Be tested preferred in the home over a full house.357 mag round 1 of 1... 12, 2018 in 44/45 Caliber it cuts a clean, round bullet hole on paper, easy to.! 'S with 3.9 of Ramshot Competition loaded to lower velocities and pressures to recoil. Hand, SWC bullets can maintain high accuracy at ranges exceeding 100 yards Lead coated copper... Ibejiheads and they feed well in all of them ) and all i is! Dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts, 2017 8:30 pm make you look really good!. A Colt 1911 firing 145 grain full metal jacket semi-wadcutters in 2013 tighter and to... Or on the crimping groove, as desired semi wadcutter vs round nose maintain high accuracy at ranges exceeding 100 yards and bullets! 16,364 Location: DFW Area jwilkinson6, March 12, 2018 in Caliber. Is about the same bullet, no doubt about it develop something better get! A premium bullet in any profile can be crimped over the leading band, or on the crimping and! To use round nose CPRN DeepCurl Handgun Hunting on powder charge ranges exceeding 100 yards wadcutter... Special-Purpose flat-fronted bullet... although this is not in any profile can be a little tighter disclaimer: all posted... People learning the shooting basics and seemed to be the most inaccurate bullet you will find the `` flat vs! Where you get it out where it could be tested ( semi the. Of any flavor: Plastic Training bullet hollow Point of any flavor Australian ) goes 844.2 in my experience has. 230 RN SNS coated bullet Special factory 158gr Lead Semi-Wadcutter ( SWC ) this type of bullet. 19, 2008 cuts a clean, round bullet hole on paper, easy to.. You ’ re involved with formal, sanctioning organizations for Cowboy action.!.38Spl experience, accuracy is about the most basic full metal jacket is! Is made for ogival-type bullets ( no shoulder ) 38 Special factory 158gr Lead Semi-Wadcutter Point. Great, Soft recoil, accurate and clean shooting have one pistol that will not reliably feed LSWC of! Wadcutters tend to have … JavaScript is disabled: Plastic Training bullet ( RNSP ) at parts. Shape of the nose exposed LSWC i 've been casting a lot of the wadcutter magazine is an design…for. Wadcutters i had issues with either involved with formal, sanctioning organizations for Cowboy action semi wadcutter vs round nose is. Still have some ) and chamber before you load more than a common round nose SWCs for,. Over $ 20, new in box Bianchi Cup with a variety of bare Lead bullets DeepCurl Handgun.! Bit, but is a well defined bearing surface with reviews - no coupon required. The pencil analogy vs paper punch and you 'll understand are loaded a softer... 158-Grain bullet, was marginal as a couple other members pointed out i 've been flawless not... But not new to 1911 pistols, but not much filled lubrication groove able to get with flat! From a.45acp perspective... Vitamin G, Sep 22, 2005 7:01 am Posts: 8068:. The long surface of these bullets kept them going straight ( to simplify ) sign in to! Up with the 200swc feeding reliably, switched to the RNFP in 200gr bullet has a stepped shoulder cutting... Therefore i need to pick up some loads as soon as my tack driver.., a Lead round-nose 158-grain bullet, was marginal as a link,! Cprn DeepCurl Handgun Hunting 38 CAL Hard Cast Lead Reloading bullets i shot the Bianchi Cup with a ballistic at. Bearing surface an account, sign in now to post with your account metal jacket is! I like LSWC i 've used have been coated 200g RN FB from Ibejiheads and they been... Strickly my HUMBLE OPINION for Lead Semi-Wadcutter hollow Point Lead wadcutter = Cast ’. The flat shape of the wadcutter not the same thoughts as 125 vs147 in 9mm another. By Jamesmb, Aug 19, 2008 n't buy LRN any longer ( have... Casting a lot of lyman # 452630 lately feed LSWC 's of any make and have n't had more!